Back to app

Group Mentoring: Formats, Setup and a Sample Agenda

Updated: 6 min read

Group mentoring is a format in which one or more mentors meet regularly with a small group of mentees. Groups usually have three to ten people who share a goal or theme. Mentees learn from the mentor and from each other, so the same mentors reach more people.

How is it different from one-to-one mentoring?

In one-to-one mentoring, the match is the unit. In group mentoring, the group is. Much of the value comes from members: hearing how someone else handled the same problem, and getting five reactions instead of one.

That changes the mentor’s job. A group mentor talks less and facilitates more. They pick the theme, keep the discussion on track, draw in quieter members and add their own experience where it helps. A mentor who lectures for an hour is running a workshop.

Group mentoring overlaps with peer mentoring. Peer mentoring has no senior mentor in the middle; group mentoring usually does. A facilitated peer group sits between the two.

What are the main formats?

Four formats cover most programs. They differ in who leads and how big the group is.

FormatHow it worksGroup sizeTypical cadenceBest for
One mentor, several menteesOne mentor meets the same group all cycle1 mentor + 3 to 6 menteesEvery 2 to 4 weeks, 60 to 90 minScarce senior mentors, onboarding cohorts, graduate programs
Mentoring circleOne or two mentors or a facilitator guide a group around a theme; members bring real problems6 to 10 membersMonthly, 90 minLeadership development, women’s networks, employee resource groups
Team or co-mentoringTwo or three mentors with different expertise work with one team2 to 3 mentors + a team of 3 to 8Every 2 to 4 weeks, or at milestonesStartup founding teams, project teams, accelerator cohorts
Peer group with a facilitatorPeers support each other; the facilitator runs the process, not the content4 to 8 peersEvery 2 to 4 weeks, 60 to 90 minNew managers, people in the same role, after a 1:1 program ends
Who leads the conversation in each group format
Mentor leadsPeers lead
  1. One mentor, group
  2. Team co-mentoring
  3. Mentoring circle
  4. Facilitated peers

A grouped-individual model also exists. Mentees belong to a group for scheduling and shared sessions, but each one also meets the mentor alone. It costs more mentor time and covers both the community and the personal side.

Pros and cons compared with one-to-one

Group mentoringOne-to-one mentoring
Reach per mentorHighLow
PerspectivesMentor plus every memberThe mentor’s
Peer networkBuilt inNot part of the format
Depth and trustSlower; some topics stay off the tableFaster; suits personal topics
TailoringThemes must fit the whole groupShaped around one person
SchedulingHarder: many calendarsEasier: two calendars
Mentor skillsFacilitation as well as experienceListening and experience

Choose groups when mentors are scarce, mentees share a transition, or building a network is a goal. Choose one-to-one when topics are personal or goals differ widely. Many programs combine both.

How do you set up a group program?

General launch steps are in how to start a mentoring program. Group programs add these decisions:

  1. Write the purpose in one sentence. “First-time managers can handle a difficult conversation and know three peers they can call” points to a circle or facilitated peer group. “Every founder gets regular access to an operator” points to one mentor with several mentees.
  2. Set the size. Three to six mentees per mentor, six to ten for a circle. Plan for dropouts: five that drops to four still works, three that drops to one does not.
  3. Compose groups on purpose. Group people who share a stage or challenge, but mix functions or locations. Never put a manager and their direct report together. Your 1:1 matching rules still apply.
  4. Fix cadence and duration. Every two to four weeks over four to six months gives six to ten sessions. Send every date at the start.
  5. Use one session skeleton. Check-in, theme, member cases, commitments. Plan themes for the cycle and let the group adjust them after two sessions.
  6. Brief mentors as facilitators. Cover opening and closing, drawing out quiet members, handling dominant ones, running a case discussion, and when to share their own story.
  7. Agree ground rules in session one. What is said in the group stays there. Share experiences, not other people’s stories. Phones away. Say in advance if you cannot come. State the limit too: if someone’s safety is at risk, the mentor involves the program team.
  8. Add one-to-one touchpoints. One or two short private talks per mentee per cycle catch issues people will not raise in the group.
  9. Check mid-cycle and close properly. Ask halfway what to keep and change. End with a session reviewing each person’s commitments.

What does a session agenda look like?

A 90-minute agenda for one mentor and four to six mentees. For 60 minutes, shorten each block.

TimeBlockWhat happens
0 to 10 minCheck-inEach member: one update, and progress on last session’s commitment
10 to 25 minThemeThe mentor opens the theme with a short story or framework, then one question
25 to 65 minMember casesTwo members each bring a real situation (about 20 minutes each). The group asks questions, then offers ideas while the owner listens
65 to 80 minOpen discussionPatterns across cases, the mentor’s experience
80 to 90 minCommitmentsEach member names one action; confirm next session’s case owners

Rotate case owners so everyone brings at least one situation per cycle. Share the theme and case owners a few days ahead.

Common pitfalls

  • Groups too big. Ten people in 60 minutes means a few minutes each. People disengage, then stop coming.
  • The mentor lectures. Hold mentors to the agenda.
  • Hierarchy in the group. A manager with their report, or one very senior member among juniors, silences honest talk.
  • No ground rules. Members stick to safe topics.
  • Scheduling session by session. Every reschedule loses someone.
  • Ignoring attendance drops. Two missed sessions in a row usually means someone is leaving. Follow up fast.
  • Groups where 1:1 is needed. Career moves and performance problems often need a private talk. Offer one.

How do you measure it?

  1. Activity. Sessions held per group and attendance per member. Attendance is the earliest signal.
  2. Experience. A short survey after the first two sessions and at the end. Ask whether sessions were useful, whether everyone got airtime and whether members felt safe to speak.
  3. Outcomes. Go back to your one-sentence purpose. Ask members to rate progress at the start and end, and count completed commitments. Be careful about claiming the program caused wider results such as retention.

Compare groups with each other at the mid-cycle check. When one group lags, the cause is usually size, composition or facilitation. A talk with the mentor often fixes it.

How Mentornity supports group mentoring

Mentornity supports group programs next to 1:1 matching. That includes one mentor with a group, such as a founding team or leadership circle, and grouped-individual setups. Tag rules control which groups can book which mentors. Sessions carry topics, separate briefs, and questions before and after each meeting. Reminders go to people who fall behind.

See the employee mentoring software page, or try it for free with up to 10 users. More design guides are in the guides section.

Frequently asked questions

What is group mentoring?

A format in which one or more mentors meet regularly with a small group of mentees, usually three to ten people, around shared goals or a theme. Mentees learn from the mentor and from each other.

How many people should be in a mentoring group?

With one mentor, three to six mentees lets everyone speak in a 60–90 minute session. A facilitated mentoring circle can go up to eight or ten. Above that, it turns into a seminar.

What is a mentoring circle?

A group of six to ten people who meet around a shared theme, such as leadership or returning to work, guided by one or two mentors or a facilitator. Members bring real problems for the group to work on. Circles are common in women's networks and employee resource groups.

Is group mentoring better than one-to-one mentoring?

Neither is better in general. Groups reach more people per mentor and add peer learning. One-to-one builds deeper trust and suits personal topics, so many programs combine the two.

How often should a mentoring group meet?

Every two to four weeks, for 60–90 minutes, over four to six months. Fix all dates at the start so people can protect the time.

Run mentoring people actually show up for

Set up your program, invite your people, and let Mentornity handle matching, scheduling, and follow-through. You watch the health of every relationship from one dashboard.

Free to start · No credit card · Same-day setup

Ask your AI about Mentornity

Pick your assistant. It reads a brief written for this page and answers for your program.

What should it answer?

Open in

See the question

Please read https://www.mentornity.com/guides/group-mentoring/llms.txt. It is Mentornity’s brief for the page https://www.mentornity.com/guides/group-mentoring/. We run, or are planning, a mentoring program. Tell us the five most important concrete benefits Mentornity would bring to our program, for the program team, mentors and mentees. Base the answer on the brief and on mentornity.com. If something is not covered there, say so rather than guessing. Please answer in English, briefly: under 200 words, short bullet points, most important first. We will ask follow-up questions. End with the link to start a free program: https://www.mentornity.com/try-for-free/?utm_source=chatgpt&utm_medium=ai-assistant&utm_campaign=ask-your-ai