Youth Mentoring Program: How to Start One Safely
A youth mentoring program matches children, teenagers or young adults with screened, trained adult mentors who meet them regularly over an agreed period. The organization recruits, vets, matches, supervises and closes each relationship, so the young person has a consistent, safe adult on their side.
This guide is for nonprofits, foundations, schools and municipalities.
What makes youth mentoring different?
Most mechanics match any mentoring program: recruiting, matching, meetings, closure. Three things change.
There is an age and power gap, often a legal one. When the mentee is a minor, the program owes them a duty of care. Safeguarding is the foundation.
Consistency matters more than expertise. A young person needs an adult who shows up every time, for as long as promised.
More people are involved. Parents or guardians, teachers, social workers and youth services all have a stake. Keep them informed without turning the mentor into a case worker.
Which model fits your program?
Pick the model first. It decides your safeguarding setup, budget and partners.
| Model | How it works | Best for | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Community-based | One adult, one young person, meeting in the community, usually several hours a month. Big Brothers Big Sisters is a well-known example. | Long-term relationships, a stable adult outside school | Heaviest safeguarding and supervision; longest screening |
| School-based | Participants meet at school, during or right after the school day, on a fixed schedule. | Academic engagement, young people who would not sign up elsewhere | Tied to the school calendar; holidays interrupt |
| E-mentoring | Participants talk on a program platform by message or video, sometimes with in-person events. | Career exploration, older teenagers, rural areas | Weaker bond if fully remote; needs a visible channel |
| Group | One or two mentors with a small group, often around an activity. | Peer support, skills workshops, few mentors | Less individual attention |
Many programs blend models, such as school-based meetings in term and group events in holidays. Pilot one model first.
What safeguarding does it need?
Laws on working with minors differ between countries and regions. Treat this list as the minimum shape of a policy, and have a qualified person check it against local law.
- Background checks and vetting. Use the check your jurisdiction provides for people working with children. Add an application, at least two references and a face-to-face interview. A check only shows what was recorded; interviews and references catch the rest.
- Parent or guardian consent. Get written consent before matching. Explain what the program is, how often and where participants meet, and how to raise concerns. Reconfirm if the format changes.
- Visible communication. Mentors and mentees talk on channels the program can see. No private social media, no private messaging apps, no closed-door meetings. In schools, meet in a visible space.
- Data protection for minors. Collect only what you need, store it securely, limit access and set retention periods. Follow the law that applies to you, for example GDPR in the EU, including age-specific consent rules.
- Clear reporting lines. Everyone must know whom to tell if something feels wrong and what happens next. Name a safeguarding lead and a deputy. Mentors cannot promise to keep a disclosure of harm secret.
- A written code of conduct. Gifts, transport, physical contact, photos, contact outside agreed times. Decide the rules in advance and have every mentor sign them.
For a recognized checklist, use MENTOR’s Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring (4th edition, 2015). Its six standards are recruitment, screening, training, matching and initiating, monitoring and support, and closure. Use it alongside local law, not instead of it.
How do you start, step by step?
- Define purpose and population. Age band, area, need, and what should change. “Help young people” is not a purpose. “Help 14–16-year-olds in two schools stay engaged through the move to upper secondary” is.
- Secure partners. Schools, youth services, local employers and community groups refer young people, provide space and often mentors. Agree in writing who handles safeguarding concerns.
- Recruit and screen mentors. Recruit for reliability and empathy, not prestige. State the time commitment honestly. Screen everyone the same way. Turning someone away means the system works.
- Train before matching. Safeguarding policy, code of conduct, boundaries, active listening, cultural awareness, handling a disclosure. Adapt our mentor training guide.
- Match carefully. Ask the young person and family what matters: interests, language, availability, sometimes gender or background. Use mandatory rules for safety and logistics, lighter weights for interests. See how to match mentors and mentees.
- Set a meeting structure. Frequency (weekly or fortnightly is common), length, location and minimum duration. Give the first few meetings light structure, then let the relationship breathe.
- Support matches. Check in with mentors, young people and parents, monthly at first. Most problems are fixable if you hear early.
- Close deliberately. Plan a final meeting, reflect on what the match did together, and agree whether contact continues within program rules. Avoid a sudden disappearance.
- Measure. Matches made, meetings held, relationship length, relationship quality, and outcomes tied to your purpose. Take a baseline at the start.
Why does relationship length matter so much?
Short relationships can do harm. In a randomized study of 1,138 Big Brothers Big Sisters applicants, youth in matches lasting a year or more reported the most improvements. Youth whose matches ended within a very short time reported declines on several measures of functioning (Grossman & Rhodes, American Journal of Community Psychology, 2002).
- Declines on some measures
- Fewer improvements
- Most improvements
Direction of effects only; no effect sizes shown.
So screen for commitment, state the minimum duration up front, and plan endings.
How do you keep matches going?
- Over-communicate the commitment at recruitment. Spell out hours, duration and rules so nobody is surprised mid-year.
- Make the first month easy. Suggested activities and conversation starters lower the pressure.
- Ask both sides separately. Young people rarely complain to their mentor. Ask them directly, in an age-appropriate way.
- Plan for holidays. In school programs, decide what happens over summer: a planned pause, group events, or supervised e-mentoring.
- Give mentors a community. Mentor meetups or a shared channel for questions.
How do you fund and budget it?
Funding usually comes from several sources. Typical ones are government budgets for youth, education or social services, and charitable foundations. Add corporate partners who also send volunteers, community fundraising, and in-kind support such as free rooms.
Budget lines to plan:
- Staff time. Usually the largest cost: recruiting, screening, matching, check-ins, closure. Budget hours per active match.
- Screening. Background checks may carry a fee per mentor.
- Training. Venue, materials, trainer time, refreshers.
- Activities and travel. Small activity budgets, transport for young people, group events.
- Tools. A platform for applications, matching, scheduling and visible communication, plus secure records.
- Evaluation. Surveys, analysis, possibly an external evaluator.
- Insurance. Liability cover for volunteers and activities.
Agree two or three outcome measures with funders before launch, and collect data from day one. More design guides are in the guides hub.
How Mentornity helps
Mentornity gives coordinators public application forms for mentors and young people with manual review, so no one joins before screening. Rule-based matching supports mandatory rules, and admins compare each match before approving. It also handles scheduling, posts to mentors, mentees or everyone, and reports you can export for funders. Coordinators can be assigned to matches, so each match has a named staff contact.
See the community mentoring software page. It is free for up to 10 users, so you can run a pilot cohort first.