Build vs Buy a Mentoring Platform: Do You Need Software?
Build vs buy for a mentoring platform comes down to three options. Run the program with spreadsheets, forms and calendars. Build your own tool. Or buy mentoring software. Spreadsheets suit small pilots, building suits teams that already ship software, and buying suits most programs that need to grow.
This guide is vendor-neutral. If the category is new to you, start with what mentoring software is.
The three options
Every program needs the same jobs done: collect applications, match people, help them meet, keep them going, and report. The question is who does those jobs.
- Do it yourself (DIY). Google Sheets or Excel for the participant list, Google Forms or Microsoft Forms for applications and feedback, shared calendars and email for meetings.
- Build in-house. Your developers create a mentoring tool, or add mentoring to an intranet, LMS or HR system.
- Buy. Subscribe to software that already covers applications, matching, scheduling, reminders and reporting.
How DIY, build and buy compare
| Criterion | DIY (sheets, forms, calendar) | Build in-house | Buy mentoring software |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setup effort | Low: forms and a sheet | High: design, development, testing, security review | Low to medium: configure a program, import participants |
| Matching at scale | Manual; slow beyond a few dozen people | Whatever you build | Usually built in, with rules or self-selection |
| Scheduling | Email and calendar invites | Calendar and video integrations you maintain | Usually built in: availability, booking, calendar sync |
| Reminders | Manual emails from the coordinator | Scheduled jobs, email delivery, templates | Usually automated |
| Reporting | Rebuilt by hand each time | Every new question is a new feature | Standard reports and exports |
| Data protection | Depends on sharing discipline | Your responsibility end to end | Shared: vendor secures the platform, you control access |
| Maintenance owner | The coordinator | Your engineering team, indefinitely | The vendor |
| Cost type | Staff time | Development budget plus ongoing engineering | Subscription plus some admin time |
DIY is not free: it costs coordinator time, and that grows with every participant. Building is not a one-time cost either. Someone has to keep the tool running after the project team moves on.
Build only when mentoring is part of what you sell.
A DIY setup that works
DIY is a sensible way to run a first pilot. You learn what the program needs before you commit to anything.
- Write your matching criteria first. Pick three to five: goals, skills or field, seniority, time zone, language. Ask mentors and mentees the same questions.
- Create two forms. One for mentors, one for mentees. Use dropdowns and checkboxes; free text is hard to match on.
- Collect everything in one sheet. Add columns for match status, match date, first meeting date and last check-in.
- Match by hand. Filter by your criteria, propose matches, and have a second person review them. Note why each match was matched.
- Send introductions. Email each match with names, the reason for the match, and what to cover in the first meeting.
- Let participants book meetings. Mentors share a booking link or a few time slots. Matches add their own video links.
- Check in every three or four weeks. Ask: have you met, was it useful, do you need help. Copy answers into the main sheet.
- Close with a survey. Summarize participants matched, matches that met, satisfaction, and what to change.
Lock down sharing on the sheet from day one. It holds personal data, and a link shared “with anyone” is easy to forward. In the EU and UK, the GDPR applies to this data whatever tool you use.
Signs you have outgrown spreadsheets
DIY does not break on a specific day. It gets slower until the coordinator spends most of their time maintaining it. Watch for these signs:
- Matching takes days, and you are unsure the matches are the best available.
- Participants go quiet and nobody notices until the end-of-cycle survey.
- Reminders depend on one person and stop when that person is on leave.
- Several cohorts live in copies of the same sheet, and nobody knows which is current.
- Every report is a rebuild. Each question from leadership or a funder costs someone a day.
- Too many people can edit a file full of personal data.
- Participants ask for more: mentor profiles, a booking page, program resources.
If three or more sound familiar, choose between building and buying. Our guide to managing a mentoring program covers the daily work any tool should make lighter.
Hidden costs of building in-house
The first version is often quick. The costs come afterwards, and most of them recur.
- Maintenance. Calendar and video APIs, browsers and email deliverability rules change. Each change needs a developer, and mentoring tools rarely top the backlog.
- Feature growth. The first request after launch is “can we also…”: a second program, group mentoring, a new report, a certificate. Each one is a new project.
- Security and data protection. Access control, encryption, backups, audits and deletion requests become yours. Under the GDPR these duties apply to internal tools too.
- Accessibility. Meeting a standard such as WCAG takes design and testing, and every change needs checking again.
- Localization. Each language means translating the interface, emails and help texts, and every new feature adds strings.
- Knowledge risk. When the developer who built it leaves, nobody wants to touch it.
Building still makes sense in three cases. Mentoring is a feature of a product you sell, it must live inside a platform your users never leave, or no product covers your needs. Otherwise, compare the ongoing cost of ownership with a subscription.
What buying changes
Buying moves maintenance, platform security and most feature work to a vendor. In return you pay a subscription and accept the product’s way of working. The risks are a tool that does not fit your program, or one priced for a much larger organization.
Define requirements first and test with a real pilot. Our guide on how to choose mentoring software has a checklist, a scoring method and vendor questions. You can also compare the best mentoring software on public facts, or see the free mentoring software options for a pilot.
Decision checklist
Answer these with the people who will run the program. See where most answers land.
| Question | Points to DIY | Points to build | Points to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Participants in year one? | Up to a few dozen | Any size | Dozens to thousands |
| Programs or cohorts? | One | Any | Several, or more planned |
| Pilot or long-term? | Pilot | Long-term, core to your product | Long-term |
| Coordinator time each week? | Plenty | Some | Little |
| Developers free for years, not months? | Not needed | Yes | Not needed |
| Is mentoring part of a product you sell? | No | Yes | No |
| Reminders and reports without manual work? | No | You will build them | Yes |
| Clear answers on data protection? | Hard to give | Yours to provide | Ask the vendor in writing |
| More than one language? | Manageable by hand | You must translate | Check the vendor’s languages |
A common path is one DIY pilot, then software for the second cohort. Keep your matching questions and feedback forms: they become the starting setup in any tool. More help is in our mentoring guides.
Where Mentornity fits
Mentornity is free for up to 10 users with every feature switched on, which suits a pilot. You can import participants from Excel or publish application forms, and match with a rule-based algorithm whose weights you can see (mentor matching software). Mentees book mentors’ time slots with automatic video links and calendar sync. Admins send reminders and export reports as Excel or PDF.
The interface runs in English, Turkish, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Dutch, French and German. Pricing is published per country. Create a free program for your next pilot.