How to Choose Mentoring Software: Buyer's Checklist
Start from your program, not from feature lists. Define the program type, size and three must-haves. Score two or three platforms against a weighted checklist, watch each vendor run the admin workflow live, and pilot the strongest one before you sign.
This guide is vendor-neutral. If you are still deciding whether you need a platform at all, read what mentoring software is first.
- 1Write requirementsOne page, three must-haves
- 2ShortlistTwo or three vendors
- 3Send questionsSame RFP to each
- 4Watch demosAdmin view, live
- 5ScoreWeighted, separately
- 6PilotReal cohort, full cycle
- 7DecideScorecard plus cost
Decide five things before any demo
Without your own requirements, every demo looks good. Agree on these with the people who will run the program:
- Program type: employee, university or alumni, accelerator, nonprofit or community.
- Size and shape: active mentors and mentees in year one and year three; one program or several; yearly cohorts or rolling enrollment.
- Who runs it: a full-time manager or someone with two hours a week. Low admin capacity makes automation matter more.
- Hard constraints: SSO, data residency, accessibility, interface languages, procurement rules.
- Three must-haves. Not ten. Missing any one rules a vendor out.
Put this on one page. It opens your RFP and is the yardstick for every demo.
What each program type needs
| Program type | Must have | Often important | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employee (HR, L&D) | SSO, admin roles, matching on skills and goals, leadership reports | Several programs in one account, HR data import | Long implementation; prices that climb with headcount |
| University and alumni | Public application forms, matching by field, cohorts by year | Certificates, access for alumni outside SSO, mobile use | Tools that assume a company email |
| Accelerator and incubator | Founders booking mentor time, group mentoring, mentor availability | Office hours, expertise tags, cohort reports for funders | Platforms built only for long 1:1 matches |
| Nonprofit and community | Low admin effort, simple matching, predictable cost | Volunteer onboarding, several languages, funder reports | Enterprise-sized contracts |
If you run more than one type, check that one account handles both.
The 14-point checklist
Ask the vendor to show each area, not describe it.
| # | Area | What to check | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Matching | Visible, editable rules and weights; admin review; self-selection option | “The algorithm decides” with no reason given |
| 2 | Scheduling | Mentor availability, booking, calendar sync, video links | Every meeting arranged by email |
| 3 | Sessions and goals | Session agendas, goal tracking, pre- and post-meeting questions | Only a free-text notes field |
| 4 | Communication | Reminders, announcements, messaging, emails in each person’s language | No way to target inactive matches |
| 5 | Reporting | Participation, meetings, feedback, CSV/Excel/PDF export | Dashboard screenshots only |
| 6 | Admin and roles | Several admins, coordinators with limited scope | One shared admin login |
| 7 | Multi-program | Several programs or cohorts, each with own settings | A new contract per program |
| 8 | Branding | Logo, colors, own domain, email sender name | Branding on a tier with no price |
| 9 | SSO | SAML or your identity provider, plus access for outsiders | SSO “on the roadmap” |
| 10 | Data protection | DPA, hosting location, deletion on request, GDPR or the local data protection law | No written hosting answer |
| 11 | Languages | Participants’ languages in interface and emails | Only the marketing site translated |
| 12 | Pricing | Written price for your user count, user definition, add-ons | Price only after several calls |
| 13 | Support | Who answers, in which language, how fast, at what cost | Generic ticket form only |
| 14 | Implementation | Time from contract to first matches, and your tasks | Multi-month project for a pilot |
For row 1, see mentor matching software.
Score vendors with weights
- Weight each area: 3 for must-have, 2 for important, 1 for nice to have, 0 if not needed.
- Score each vendor 0–5 per area, only on what you saw: 0 = missing, 1 = promised, 3 = works with workarounds, 5 = shown live.
- Multiply and add. Weight times score, summed, gives a total.
- Apply a knockout rule. A 0 or 1 on any must-have rules the vendor out, whatever its total.
- Score separately first. Two or three people score alone before discussing.
Example: matching has weight 3 and Vendor A scores 5, so that row adds 15. If SSO is a must-have and Vendor B scores 1, Vendor B is out even with a higher total.
RFP and demo questions
Send written questions first, then use the demo to see the answers. Ask for the admin view.
Matching
- Show us how you would match 50 mentees to 20 mentors with our profile fields. Why was each match suggested?
- Can an admin change a match, and what happens to booked meetings?
- Can participants choose their own mentor?
Daily operation
- How does an admin find participants who have not met in a month and nudge them?
- Which reminders are automatic, and can each be turned off?
- How do we run a second program or next year’s cohort?
Data and access
- Where is our data hosted? Can we see your data processing agreement?
- How does SSO work, and how do people outside our identity provider join?
- How do we export or delete our data if we leave?
Commercial
- What is the full price for our active users, including SSO, white labeling, setup and support?
- What counts as a user: invited, active or matched?
- What happens to the price if we double in year two?
Implementation
- How long from signature to first matches, and who does what?
- In which languages and channels is support offered?
Ask every vendor the same questions so the answers can be compared.
Run a pilot
Treat the pilot as a small real program.
- Pick a real cohort of 10–30 people who will actually meet.
- Set success criteria first, such as all participants matched within a week, most matches holding two meetings, and manageable admin time.
- Run a full cycle: invite, match, schedule, meet, collect feedback, export a report.
- Log admin effort, including every manual step and workaround.
- Decide with the scorecard, updated with what the pilot showed.
- Invite and match
- First meetings
- Second meetings
- Feedback and report
Prefer vendors that let you pilot without a long contract, through a free plan or a trial.
Build or buy
A matching form and a spreadsheet are quick to build. Scheduling, calendar integrations, reminders, permissions, reporting and security reviews are not, and they need maintenance. Building makes sense mainly when mentoring is part of a product you already sell. See building versus buying a mentoring platform.
Estimate total cost of ownership
Fill this in for each vendor over the contract term, usually three years:
| Cost line | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subscription for expected active users | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Add-ons (SSO, white label, extra programs) | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Setup or implementation fees | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Internal admin time (hours x hourly cost) | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Training and launch effort | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Support or success package | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Integration or IT work | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
| Total | [amount] | [amount] | [amount] |
Admin time is the line people forget. A cheaper tool that needs more manual follow-up can cost more over three years. Compare the best mentoring software on public facts, or see free mentoring software if budget is tight. More help is in our mentoring guides.
How Mentornity fits this checklist
Mentornity is free for up to 10 users with every feature on. Pricing is published per country with no setup fees; SAML SSO and white labeling are priced separately. It has rule-based matching with visible weights, availability booking with video links and calendar sync, structured sessions, reminders, and CSV, Excel or PDF exports. The interface runs in English, Turkish, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Dutch, French and German. Create a free program and score it like any other vendor.