Mentoring Program Report: How to Report Results
A mentoring program report tells a sponsor what the program delivered, how well it worked and what should happen next. It fits on one page, and every number sits next to a target set before the cohort began.
This guide covers presenting results. To decide what to measure, start with the mentoring program evaluation guide.
Who reads the report and what they want
Write the headline for the person who decides the next budget, then adapt for everyone else.
| Reader | Their question | Put first | Format |
|---|---|---|---|
| Executive sponsor | Is this worth continuing or growing? | Headline, delivery against targets, the decision you need | One page, three to five numbers |
| HR or L&D team | Is it running well, and where is it leaking? | Match rate, active matches, drop-off, session completion | Monthly table or dashboard |
| Funder or board | Did we deliver what was funded, to whom? | Reach, delivery, the indicators in the grant | Report against targets, plus stories |
| Mentors and mentees | Did our time matter? What changes next? | What participants said and what will change | Short email |
| Participants’ managers | What does this mean for my team? | Time spent, goals, how to support | A paragraph |
Do not send the operational dashboard to leadership. And always tell participants what happened with their feedback, so they have a reason to answer next time.
The one-page report
Use the same seven sections every cohort, so readers know where to look and cohorts can be compared.
- Headline. What the program delivered and the most important finding. Write it last.
- Participation. Who applied, was eligible, was matched, and who was left out and why.
- Activity. Meetings held, sessions completed, matches still active at the end.
- Quality. Satisfaction and goal progress from the evaluation survey, with the response rate next to each figure.
- Outcome indicators. Only those the program aimed to influence, next to a comparison group where you can.
- Stories. Two or three short, consented examples.
- Next steps. What you will change, what you need, by when.
Fill-in outline
[Program name], Cohort ________ report (period: ________ to ________)
Headline: In this cohort, ________ mentees and ________ mentors took part. ________ of ________ matches were still meeting at the end. The main finding is ________.
Participation: ________ applications against a target of ________. ________ eligible applicants, ________ matched (match rate ________). Not matched: ________, because ________.
Activity: ________ meetings held, an average of ________ per active match against a plan of ________. Session completion: ________. Drop-off: ________ matches, mostly in week ________.
Quality: Satisfaction ________ (scale ________, ________ responses out of ________). Mentees rated progress on their goals at ________ on average, from ________ at baseline.
Outcome indicators: ________ (measured ________ months after the end, compared with ________).
What participants said: ”________” (role, shared with permission).
What we will change: 1. ________ 2. ________ 3. ________
What we need: ________ by ________.
Put methods, survey wording and full tables in an appendix.
KPI definitions
Write the definitions down and keep them. A match rate calculated differently each cohort makes the trend meaningless.
| KPI | Formula | How to show it |
|---|---|---|
| Enrollment vs target | Applications ÷ target applications | One number with the target |
| Match rate | Matched participants ÷ eligible applicants | Number plus the reason for any gap |
| Time to match | Median days from application close to match | Median, not average |
| Active match rate | Matches with a meeting in the last ________ weeks ÷ all matches | Trend across the cohort |
| Meetings per active match | Meetings held ÷ active matches | Against the planned number |
| Session completion | Sessions completed ÷ sessions planned | By session, to show where matches stall |
| Drop-off | Matches ended early ÷ all matches | With timing and main reasons |
| Survey response rate | Responses ÷ people surveyed | Next to every survey figure |
| Satisfaction | Average rating on a fixed scale | With one representative comment |
| Goal progress | End rating minus baseline, per goal | Distribution, not just the average |
| Outcome indicators | Rate in mentee group vs comparison group | Labeled as association, with the period |
Leave out industry benchmarks. Published averages define metrics differently, so comparisons mislead. Compare against your target, the previous cohort and, for outcomes, a comparison group. To put results in money terms, see the mentoring program ROI guide.
- Sign-upsInterest only
- Matches that metDelivery
- Goal progressSelf-reported change
- Vs comparison groupAssociation
- Randomized designCause
Using stories and quotes ethically
Treat every quote as personal data.
- Ask before you quote. Get permission for the exact words and the attribution. A survey answer for program improvement is not consent to appear in a board pack.
- Attribute by role, such as “a first-year analyst”, unless the person asks to be named.
- Watch small groups. If only one mentee comes from a site, a role label identifies them.
- Pick representative stories. If most feedback was positive with one recurring complaint, say so.
- Do not change meaning. Shorten with an ellipsis, but never merge two people’s words.
- Keep mentoring conversations private. Use only what people chose to share for the report.
Under GDPR and similar data protection laws, tell participants at enrollment how feedback may be used, and report outcome data in aggregate.
Reporting cadence
| Cadence | Audience | Covers | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly | Program team | Match rate, active matches, overdue sessions, open feedback forms | A table |
| Midpoint | Sponsor | Delivery so far, early problems and fixes | Half a page |
| End of cohort | Leadership, funder, board | The one-page report | One page plus appendix |
| 3–12 months later | Leadership, funder | Outcome indicators that take time | Short update |
| After each report | Participants | What you heard and what will change | An email |
- Monthly team checks
- Midpoint note
- End-of-cohort report
- Outcome follow-up
The monthly check is for fixing the program. If a sponsor asks for it, send the midpoint note instead.
Common mistakes
- Vanity metrics. Sign-ups or “hours offered” say little. Lead with matches that met.
- Causal claims. Write “mentees had higher 12-month retention than a matched comparison group”, and name the group.
- Averages that hide the spread. An average of four meetings can mean half met eight times and half never met. Show the distribution.
- Figures without response rates.
- Dropping drop-outs from the denominator. It inflates every rate.
- No ask. Say what you need and by when.
- Changing definitions between cohorts.
If the report feeds a funding decision, the mentoring program business case guide shows how to turn results into a proposal.
Reporting in Mentornity
In Mentornity, participation, matches, meetings, session completion and feedback are counted while the program runs. Each booked meeting is recorded with its date, participants and session. Reports export as charts, CSV, Excel or PDF, with a Program Health score updated every week. See employee mentoring programs and women’s programs reporting to funders, or try it free with up to 10 users.