Questions to Ask a Mentor: 52 Questions by Situation
Questions to ask a mentor are the prepared questions a mentee brings to draw on the mentor’s experience and honest view of their work. The best ones are concrete, tied to a real decision, and open enough that the answer is a story.
Below are 52 questions by situation, then notes on asking well and what to avoid. For the mentor’s side, see questions mentors ask.
Why your questions shape the meeting
A mentor can only answer what you bring. They do not know which part of their experience helps you until you point at it.
“Do you have any advice for my career?” gets general principles. “I have an offer to move from analyst to team lead, and I’m not sure I want to stop doing the work myself. How did you handle that choice?” gets a story and something you can use on Monday.
Prepared questions also show you have done your thinking. See how to prepare for a mentoring meeting. Pick the two or three questions below that fit where you are now.
- Any advice?
- Topic only"How do I get promoted?"
- Your situationContext in two sentences
- A real decisionContext plus what they did
First meeting
Use it to learn how your mentor thinks and agree how you will work.
- “What made you say yes to mentoring?”
- “What has made past mentoring relationships useful for you, on either side?”
- “How do you prefer to be contacted between meetings, and what is too much?”
- “How often should we meet, and for how long, to make this worth your time?”
- “What would you like to know about me before you give me any advice?”
- “Here is the one goal I most want to work on. Does your experience cover it?”
- “What should I bring to each meeting to make it easier for you to help?”
Question 7 tells you whether your mentor wants documents, a short note in advance or just a clear topic.
Career
Ask about decisions your mentor actually made, not careers in general.
- “How did you decide when to leave a role, and what told you it was time?”
- “Looking at my experience, which paths am I not considering?”
- “What do people at the next level do differently from people at my level?”
- “Which of your career moves looked risky and turned out well? Which did not?”
- “If you were starting in this field today, what would you do in your first two years?”
- “How do you tell a job that is hard in a useful way from one that is just draining?”
- “What would you want to see from me in a year to call it real progress?”
When a direction becomes clear, make it measurable with how to set goals with your mentor.
Building a skill
Bring something real: a piece of work, a draft, a situation you handled.
- “This is a presentation I gave last week. Where did it lose people?”
- “How did you learn to do this well? What did practice look like?”
- “Which skill am I underestimating for the role I want?”
- “What is the smallest project I could take on to practice this?”
- “Who does this exceptionally well, and what do they do differently?”
- “What did you get wrong when you were learning this?”
Mistakes are specific; principles are not. That makes question 20 worth asking.
Workplace politics and relationships
Every organization has unwritten rules. A mentor from outside your team can describe them without the risk of asking a colleague.
- “How do decisions really get made in an organization like mine?”
- “My manager and I see this differently. How would you approach that conversation?”
- “How do I make my work visible without looking self-promoting?”
- “Who should I be building relationships with that I am probably ignoring?”
- “How do you disagree with someone more senior without damaging the relationship?”
- “What signals tell you a project or team is in trouble before anyone says so?”
- “How did you handle a colleague you found difficult to work with?”
Keep the focus on your own choices. Describe others only as much as your mentor needs.
Leadership
Ask about the first time your mentor did something, when the lessons were fresh.
- “What surprised you most about managing people for the first time?”
- “How did you handle the shift from peer to manager?”
- “How do you give feedback that people act on?”
- “What do you delegate, and what do you keep?”
- “How do you decide when your team disagrees with you?”
- “What did you do in your first 90 days as a leader that you would repeat?”
Feedback on yourself
A mentor has no stake in your performance review, so their view can be honest if you ask clearly.
- “What is one thing I do that holds me back?”
- “How do I come across in these meetings? Is that how I want to come across at work?”
- “Where am I selling myself short?”
- “What would worry you if you were my manager?”
- “Is my goal realistic, or am I playing it safe?”
- “What have you noticed that you haven’t told me yet?”
- “What should I stop doing?”
Ask one, then listen without defending. Take notes and decide later what to do. Arguing makes the next round of feedback less likely. More in how to ask for feedback.
Your mentor’s own story
Your mentor’s career is the source of their advice. Knowing the context makes the advice easier to apply.
- “What was the hardest decision of your career, and how did you make it?”
- “What do you know now that you wish someone had told you at my stage?”
- “Who mentored you, and what did they do that made a difference?”
- “What failure changed how you work?”
- “What has changed in this field since you started, and what has stayed the same?”
- “What are you still working on getting better at?”
- “What would you do completely differently if you started again?”
Closing a session
The last five minutes decide whether the meeting turns into action.
- “What is the one thing I should do before we meet again?”
- “Is there anyone I should talk to about this?”
- “Was this a useful hour for you? What would make the next one better?”
- “What should we start with next time?”
- “Can I send you a short update on how this goes?”
How to ask good questions
The difference between a weak and a strong question is usually specificity.
| Weak question | Stronger version |
|---|---|
| “Any advice for my career?” | “I’m choosing between two internal roles. What would you weigh that I might miss?” |
| “How do I get promoted?” | “My review said I need more visibility. What did that look like when you were promoted?” |
| “Is networking important?” | “Who in my field should I know in the next six months, and how would you approach them?” |
| “How do I become a better leader?” | “My team stopped speaking up in meetings. What would you try first?” |
- Give context first: two or three sentences, then the question.
- Ask one question at a time. Stacked questions get partial answers.
- Follow up: “What happened next?” and “What would you do in my case?”
- Rank your list. Start with what you most need, not the easiest.
- Write down the answer and report back on what you did with it.
Questions to avoid
- Questions a search would answer. Ask what the job looks like from the inside instead.
- “Can you get me a job?”, especially early. Introductions come from trust.
- “What should I do?” with no context. Ask what they would weigh, then decide yourself.
- Fishing for reassurance. “I did the right thing, didn’t I?” If you want an honest view, ask for one.
- Gossip about named people. It puts your mentor in an awkward spot.
- Overly personal questions. Salary, health and family are your mentor’s to raise.
For program coordinators
You can make good questions the default. Share a short list of suggested questions before each meeting, and ask both sides to record a few lines afterward. Mentees get a starting point, and you see which matches are working.
Mentornity does this with structured sessions: meeting topics with separate briefs for mentor and mentee, and questions before and after each meeting. It is free for up to 10 users, enough for a small pilot. See employee mentoring programs or browse the other mentoring guides.