Back to app

Mentoring Program Models: Matched, Pool, Group & More

Updated: 4 min read

A mentoring program model in Mentornity is the combination of three independent choices: whether members are matched (matched or pool), whether meetings follow a plan (structured or freestyle), and whether mentees take part as individuals or groups. Labels like “structured matched mentoring” or “startup mentoring pool” are just combinations of these. Answer each question on its own, and the combination is your model.

Three choices that define a program model
  1. 1Matched?Matched or pool
  2. 2Session plan?Structured or freestyle
  3. 3Who meets?Individual or group
  4. 4Role namesLabels only, no change in behavior

Matched or pool

Matched programs have a matching step. The admin, the matching algorithm or the mentee choosing a mentor decides who works with whom, and the match persists. Matched programs have a Matching area in the admin panel with a matching mode and matching rules. Its Coordination Center tracks every active match’s meeting progress.

Pool programs skip matching. A mentee looks at a mentor’s published availability and books a slot, like any appointment. There is no persistent match, and a mentee can book different mentors for different needs. This suits open communities and skill-sharing networks.

Matched programs also have a matching mode, covered in the matching guide. There are four: the admin matches people directly, or mentees request a match that the admin approves, or one the mentor approves, or mentees select a mentor and start at once. These modes only change how a match starts; they are not a separate model.

Structured or freestyle

Structured programs run on a predefined set of sessions that the admin defines in advance. Each session has its own description for mentors and mentees, optional attachments, and optional questions before or after the meeting. Progress is tracked session by session, and certificate eligibility is based on completing sessions and their forms.

Freestyle programs have no session plan. Meetings are created whenever a mentor or mentee wants one. Feedback comes from general feedback questions, and certificate eligibility is a minimum number of meetings plus feedback responses.

Neither is more advanced. A fixed-length onboarding or training program usually benefits from a session plan, because every match should cover the same ground. An open-ended relationship often works better freestyle, with the match setting its own agenda.

Individual or group

Individual programs have one mentee per meeting.

Group programs organize mentees into groups: a cohort, a team, a startup or any cluster that shares a mentor. Meetings are created for the whole group, every member is invited and sees shared meeting notes, and the admin panel gains a Groups tab next to Mentors and Mentees.

Group programs combine with matched or pool, and structured or freestyle. A group pool program can also use tag-based meeting rules: whether a mentor can meet a group depends on tags assigned to that group, set once under Users.

“Entrepreneur”, “startup”, “coaching”: labels, not models

These names are not separate products. Beyond the three choices, each program has a cosmetic choice of what to call each role.

A “startup mentoring” program is a group program with the group label set to “startup” and the mentee label set to something like “entrepreneur”. A “coaching” program is any model with mentor renamed to “coach” and mentee to “coachee”. Matching, sessions, meetings, reports and certificates behave the same whatever the labels. Set them under Role Naming in the admin panel (see the admin guide); they apply across the program as soon as you save.

Choosing a model for a new program

Work through the three questions in order.

QuestionChoose matched / structured / group if…Choose pool / freestyle / individual if…
Matched or pool?You want an ongoing, accountable relationship between specific people, tracked as a match.You want on-demand help where anyone can book anyone, with no lasting match.
Structured or freestyle?Every match should cover the same ground (onboarding, a fixed curriculum, a certification path).The match should set its own agenda, meeting to meeting.
Individual or group?Mentees belong to a team, cohort or company and should be mentored together.Mentees are mentored on their own.

Common combinations:

  • Employee mentoring: usually matched, often structured for a fixed onboarding period, individual.
  • Open mentor marketplace or alumni network: usually pool, freestyle, individual.
  • Accelerator or incubator cohort: often matched, freestyle or lightly structured, and often group (one mentor with a founding team).
  • Fixed-curriculum training: usually matched, structured, individual or group depending on class size.

Changing the model later

Not through a self-serve setting. Matched or pool and individual or group are set when a program is created, and no admin setting changes them. Structured or freestyle is the exception: deleting every remaining session in a structured program switches it to freestyle, with a warning before you confirm. To add a session plan to a freestyle program, or to change matched/pool or individual/group, contact the Mentornity team.

For the screens that go with each model, read the Mentornity admin guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a matched and a pool mentoring program?

In a matched program, mentors and mentees are matched before they meet, by the admin, the matching algorithm or the mentee choosing a mentor. In a pool program there is no matching step: a mentee books any mentor's published availability, and can book different mentors for different topics.

What is the difference between structured and freestyle mentoring?

Structured programs follow a predefined session plan, each session with its own description and optional questions before and after the meeting. Freestyle programs have no plan; meetings are created as needed and feedback comes from general feedback questions.

Is group mentoring a different product from one-to-one mentoring?

No. Group mentoring works the same way, with mentees organized into groups. It combines with either matched or pool, and with either structured or freestyle.

Can I change my program's model after it launches?

Not from a self-serve settings page. Matched or pool and individual or group are set when the program is created. Contact the Mentornity team if you need a different model.

Can I rename mentor and mentee without changing how the program works?

Yes. Role names such as coach and coachee are set under Role Naming in the admin panel. They change the words members see; matching, sessions and every other setting behave the same.

Run mentoring people actually show up for

Set up your program, invite your people, and let Mentornity handle matching, scheduling, and follow-through. You watch the health of every relationship from one dashboard.

Free to start · No credit card · Same-day setup

Ask your AI about Mentornity

Pick your assistant. It reads a brief written for this page and answers for your program.

What should it answer?

Open in

See the question

Please read https://www.mentornity.com/guides/mentoring-program-models/llms.txt. It is Mentornity’s brief for the page https://www.mentornity.com/guides/mentoring-program-models/. We run, or are planning, a mentoring program. Tell us the five most important concrete benefits Mentornity would bring to our program, for the program team, mentors and mentees. Base the answer on the brief and on mentornity.com. If something is not covered there, say so rather than guessing. Please answer in English, briefly: under 200 words, short bullet points, most important first. We will ask follow-up questions. End with the link to start a free program: https://www.mentornity.com/try-for-free/?utm_source=chatgpt&utm_medium=ai-assistant&utm_campaign=ask-your-ai