Back to app

Mentoring Conversation Starters: 72 Prompts by Session

Updated: 10 min read

Mentoring conversation starters are short, open prompts that open a topic in a session, so the talk reaches something real in the first five minutes. This template has 72 of them, grouped by stage and theme, with the side that usually asks each one.

Print it, keep it next to your notes, and pick a few before each meeting. For deeper question banks, mentees can use questions to ask a mentor and mentors questions mentors ask.

How to use these starters

  1. Pick two or three per session. One good starter with honest follow-up can fill half an hour.
  2. Choose by stage. The map below shows which sections fit which point in the mentorship.
  3. Split the choice. The mentee picks one, the mentor picks one. Agree on them when you confirm the meeting.
  4. Follow up before moving on. “Tell me more”, “What happened next?” and “What would you do differently?” turn a prompt into a conversation.
  5. Date what you used, so you do not repeat yourselves and can return to a good one.
  6. Close every session with section 9. One reflection prompt makes the next meeting easier to plan.
Using starters in one session
  1. Pick two or three
  2. Ask one, follow up
  3. Agree a next step
  4. Close with reflection

Each session

Point in the mentorshipWhat the match is doingPull starters from
Session 1Getting to know each other, agreeing how to workSections 1 and 2
Sessions 2 to 3Setting directionSections 2, 3 and 4
Middle sessionsWorking on goalsSections 4, 5, 6 and 7; section 8 now and then
Midpoint reviewChecking progress, adjusting goalsSections 2, 5 and 9
Final sessionClosing and looking aheadSection 9

The template

Mentoring conversation starters sheet

  • Mentor: ________
  • Mentee: ________
  • Program (if any): ________
  • Start date: ________

Who usually asks: Mentor = usually asked by the mentor. Mentee = usually asked by the mentee. Either = works both ways. Treat these as defaults, not rules.

1. First meeting: getting to know each other

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
1“What does a good week look like for you right now?”Either________
2“What are you working on that you genuinely enjoy?”Either________
3“What is the short version of how you got to where you are?”Either________
4“What made you sign up for this program?”Either________
5“What kind of help is most useful to you: advice, questions, introductions or a sounding board?”Mentor________
6“What is something about you that would not show up on your CV?”Either________
7“How do you like to get feedback: direct, gentle, in writing, on the spot?”Mentor________
8“Six months from now, what would make this feel worth the time?”Either________

2. Goals and direction

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
9“If this mentorship goes well, what will be different for you in six months?”Mentor________
10“Which of your goals would you work on even if nobody asked about it?”Mentor________
11“Which of my goals do you think matters most right now?”Mentee________
12“What have you already tried toward this goal?”Mentor________
13“What would a small win look like before our next meeting?”Either________
14“Is this goal yours, or one someone else expects of you?”Mentor________
15“What would make you change or drop this goal?”Either________
16“How will we both know you are making progress?”Either________

3. Career path

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
17“Where do you want to be in two to three years, and how sure are you about it?”Mentor________
18“Which roles around you look interesting, and what do you actually know about them?”Mentor________
19“What did you consider doing instead of your current path?”Either________
20“Which turning point in your career would you walk me through?”Mentee________
21“What kind of work gives you energy, and what drains it?”Mentor________
22“If you stayed in your current role two more years, what would you want from it?”Mentor________
23“What do people at my stage tend to get wrong about career moves?”Mentee________
24“Apart from me, whose career would you like to learn from?”Mentor________

4. Skills and learning

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
25“Which skill, improved this quarter, would make the biggest difference?”Mentor________
26“How do you learn best: reading, doing, or watching someone else?”Either________
27“Can we look at a real piece of my work together next time?”Mentee________
28“Which skill took you longest to learn, and what finally helped?”Mentee________
29“Where could you practice this at work in the next month?”Mentor________
30“What feedback have you already had on this skill?”Mentor________
31“What would good enough look like for this skill, for now?”Either________
32“Which resource or person helped you most when you were starting out?”Mentee________

5. Feedback

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
33“What feedback would be most useful to you today?”Mentor________
34“How did our last conversation land? Was anything unhelpful?”Either________
35“Can I share what I noticed just now, honestly?”Mentor________
36“What recent feedback did you disagree with, and why?”Mentor________
37“How well do I prepare for these meetings, from your side?”Mentee________
38“What is one thing that would make these sessions more useful?”Either________
39“Which piece of feedback changed how you work?”Mentee________
40“What did you do with the feedback from last time?”Mentor________

6. Challenges and obstacles

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
41“What has been the hardest part of the last two weeks?”Mentor________
42“What is in your way that you have not said out loud yet?”Mentor________
43“Where do you feel stuck, and since when?”Mentor________
44“How have you handled something like this before?”Either________
45“Which part of this problem is actually in your control?”Mentor________
46“How would you approach this if you were in my position?”Mentee________
47“What is the worst realistic outcome, and could you live with it?”Mentor________
48“Who else could help with this, besides me?”Either________

7. Navigating the workplace or organization

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
49“Who has to say yes before your work moves forward?”Mentor________
50“Whose support would make your next step easier?”Mentor________
51“What unwritten rules did you have to learn where you work?”Mentee________
52“How visible is your work to the people who decide on your next role?”Mentor________
53“How is it going with your manager, honestly?”Mentor________
54“Is there a conversation coming up that you would like to rehearse?”Mentor________
55“How do you say no to extra work without hurting your reputation?”Mentee________
56“What do you wish you had understood about this industry earlier?”Mentee________

8. Wellbeing and balance (light check-ins)

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
57“How is your energy compared with last time we met?”Mentor________
58“What are you looking forward to outside work this month?”Either________
59“Is your workload realistic right now?”Mentor________
60“What do you do when you notice you are close to overloaded?”Either________
61“What is one thing you could take off your plate?”Mentor________
62“How do you protect time for the things that matter to you?”Mentee________

These are check-ins, not counseling. If something serious comes up, listen, and point to the right support: the program coordinator, HR, or a professional service.

9. Reflection and closing

#Conversation starterUsually asked byUsed (date)
63“What will you try before our next meeting, and by when?”Mentor________
64“What was the most useful moment of today’s conversation?”Either________
65“What do you know now that you did not know when we started?”Mentor________
66“Which of our earlier conversations do you still think about?”Either________
67“What should we spend more time on, and what less?”Either________
68“What has changed since our first meeting?”Either________
69“What will you keep doing after this mentorship ends?”Mentor________
70“How would you like to stay in touch, if at all?”Either________
71“What would you tell the next mentee in this program?”Mentor________
72“What did you get out of this mentorship, as the mentor?”Mentee________

Session planner

SessionDateStarters chosen (#)What we agreed to do next
1________________________
2________________________
3________________________
4________________________
5________________________
6________________________

Questions to avoid early on

Save these until trust is built, or leave them out entirely:

  • “Can you get me a job or refer me?” Introductions follow trust. Asked in session one, it turns the mentor into a recruiter.
  • “How much do you earn?” Ask how pay is structured in the field instead, if it matters to the goal.
  • Health, family plans, religion, politics, relationships. Only if the other person raises them.
  • “Should I quit?” In the first meeting the mentor has no context. Ask what they would weigh, later.
  • Gossip about named colleagues or the mentee’s manager. Talk about situations and patterns, not people who are not in the room.
  • Interview-style questions such as “What is your biggest weakness?” They put the other person on trial.
  • Yes or no questions. “Do you like your job?” ends the topic. “What do you like most about your job?” opens it.

How to adapt the template

Fit it to the program type.

  • Employee programs: keep section 7 and add starters about internal moves and cross-team projects. At scale, employee mentoring software can put starters into each session brief.
  • Students and early-career mentees: swap part of section 3 for internships, first jobs and choosing a specialization.
  • Founders and accelerator programs: rewrite section 7 around the team, customers and investors.
  • Peer and reverse mentoring: mark everything “Either”. Both sides teach, so both sides ask.

Adjust the tone. Formal cultures may prefer “Could you tell me about…” to “What’s…”. Keep the questions open; change only the wording.

Give each session a theme. If you run a program, assign two or three starters to each planned session. The mentoring meeting agenda template has a slot for them.

Keep it to one page per session. A long list read aloud is an interview, not a conversation.

More templates and guides are in the guides library.

Frequently asked questions

What are good conversation starters for mentoring?

Open questions that fit where the match is: getting to know each other first, then goals and career direction, then skills, feedback and obstacles, and reflection at the end. They invite a story or an example, not a yes or no.

What should I talk about with my mentor?

What you are actually working on: a goal, a decision you are weighing, a skill you are building, a tricky situation at work, or how you come across. Bring one real example to each meeting.

How many conversation starters should we use in one mentoring session?

Two or three for a 45 to 60 minute session. One good starter with real follow-up can fill half a meeting. More than three turns the session into an interview.

What topics should you avoid in a first mentoring meeting?

Asking for a job or referral, salary, and personal topics such as health, family plans, religion or politics unless the other person raises them. Hold back on big decisions like quitting until the mentor has more context.

Run mentoring people actually show up for

Set up your program, invite your people, and let Mentornity handle matching, scheduling, and follow-through. You watch the health of every relationship from one dashboard.

Free to start · No credit card · Same-day setup

Ask your AI about Mentornity

Pick your assistant. It reads a brief written for this page and answers for your program.

What should it answer?

Open in

See the question

Please read https://www.mentornity.com/guides/templates/mentoring-conversation-starters/llms.txt. It is Mentornity’s brief for the page https://www.mentornity.com/guides/templates/mentoring-conversation-starters/. We run, or are planning, a mentoring program. Tell us the five most important concrete benefits Mentornity would bring to our program, for the program team, mentors and mentees. Base the answer on the brief and on mentornity.com. If something is not covered there, say so rather than guessing. Please answer in English, briefly: under 200 words, short bullet points, most important first. We will ask follow-up questions. End with the link to start a free program: https://www.mentornity.com/try-for-free/?utm_source=chatgpt&utm_medium=ai-assistant&utm_campaign=ask-your-ai